Cast
Matt McGrath
Paul
Andy Fowle
Grady
William H. Macy
Mr. O'Day
John C. McGinley
Groundskeeper
Julianne Phillips
Justice Fitz
Will McCormack
Todd
Robert Bella
Pepe
Erik Jensen
Dean
Mary McCormack
Moira
Martha Plimpton
Ann
Chris Bauer
Tony Baby Shark
Kristen Johnston
Stalker Fan
Marley Shelton
Crying Fan
Josh Pais
Cathartic Fan
Zosia Mamet
Lost Fan
Ajax
The Dog
Casper Andreas
Mats(as Casper Andreasson)
Julie Auerbach
Neck-brace Fan(as Julie Hess)
Craig Collington Bator
Fan
Bret Bella
Interviewer
Adam Bitterman
Prediction Fan
Kate Blumberg
Shining Star Fan
Brendan Bradley
Unofficial Cover Band Fan #3
Patrick Breen
Lonely Fan
Christopher Carley
Lonely Fan
Erin Chandler
Ditsy Fan
Harry Clein
Jewish Music Fan
Ridley May Downs
Immaculate Conception Baby
Sharon Raab Downs
Immaculate Conception Fan(as Sophia Raab)
Timothy Durkin
Fan
Matt Flanders
Smoking Fan
Matt Flanders
Unofficial Cover Band Member #1
Giada Hansen
Shower Fan
George Hertzberg
Married Hippy Fan #2
Nancy Hower
Guitar Chick Fan
Antti Kaarlela
Concert Announcer
Harry Jay Knowles
Velvet Poster Fan
Jordan Lage
The J-Man Fan
Paul Marcarelli
Magical Fan #1
Mary B. McCann
Bickering Wife Fan
Heather Oakley
Dolphin Fan
Toni Pearen
Pandemonium Fan
Lena Pepe
Daughter of Bickering Fans
Neil Pepe
Bickering Husband Fan
Jenni Pulos
Loving Fan
Olivia Rosewood
Toy Piano Fan
Reed Ruby
Fan
Mark Schwahn
Venice Beach Fan
Cynthia Silver
Magical Fan #2
Mark Souza
Unofficial Cover Band Fan #2
Krista Tucker
Married Hippy Fan #1
Paul Urcioli
Vics and Tims Fan
Todd Weeks
Toilet Fan
Ali Humiston
Teddy Bear Fan(uncredited)
Marc Opitz
Fan(uncredited)
Crew
Costume & Make-Up
Kaye Voyce
Costume Design
Directing
Robert Bella
Director
Production
Tom Razzano
Producer
John C. McGinley
Producer
Patricia Wolff
Producer
Heather Baird
Casting
Robert Bella
Producer
Sound
Zach Michaelis
Sound
Jason Downs
Original Music Composer
Matthew Puckett
Original Music Composer
Pat Irwin
Original Music Composer
Writing
Tom Morrissey
Writer